Evaluation System

 

Evaluation Criteria:

  1. Content
  • Does the author have a clearly defined goal or thesis?
  • Are the arguments presented in the article original? How important are they?
  1. Depth of Analysis and Quality of Research
  • Are all ideas fully developed?
  • Is the topic studied consistently and in depth?
  • Is the author's position presented clearly and convincingly?
  • Is the author’s reasoning based on relevant information?
  1. Use of Literature / Evidence
  • Is relevant scholarly literature used?
  • Is the article based on reliable sources?
  • Are primary sources used? Has cited literature been used to develop and strengthen the presented arguments?
  • Are citations correctly referenced?
  1. Structure
  • Does the structure of the article correspond to the research objectives and tasks? Is there a need to change or improve certain sections in this regard?
  • Is more attention given to important issues and less to relatively minor details?
  • Is each issue fully examined?
  • Is the transition from one aspect of the research topic to another natural and well-grounded?
  1. Results
  • Are the research results significant, novel, and reliable?
  • Are the results logical?
  1. Final Conclusion
    (To be published as is / To be published after revisions / Not to be published)